Everything sound & ear training related

SoundGym

profile
Casper Kramer
Nov 01, 2017
Could anyone explain what's the deal with Dr. Compressor? As far as I know compression can be utilized in complete different ways. For example either to highlight transients (slow attack) or to reduce overall dynamics, and everything in between. If I don't know any of the compressor settings used in the sound examples, how can I possibly know what is going on? I mean, in some choices there's clearly that squashed sound opposed to a very clean sound which makes it quite easy to guess right, but in others I can easily imagine different compressor settings.
profile
Thomas Kumar
Nov 01, 2017
as far as I know, the attack and release settings are always the same and pretty short (read something about this topic from an official soundgym member some time ago..)
profile
Branden Oliver
Nov 02, 2017
Listen for how wide the dynamic range is. Sometimes the sound doesn't sound squashed, but the dynamics are even throughout the loop. Listen for how different the snare hits, the kicks, or the hi hat hits are. When I started listening for dynamic range, I started doing much better. Hope that helps!
profile
Juan Sanchez
Nov 02, 2017
I also look for density. When comparing I focus the first cymbal (if available) and try to figure out which one sounds longer. That's helpful, if you don't see other orientation points
profile
Gus Greely
Nov 02, 2017
I agree with Branden. At first I was able to get through by identifying the snare that sounded longer (which worked for quite a while) but when it got more subtle, I had to try to identify which one had least difference between the loudest and the quietest (dynamic range).
profile
Gus Greely
Nov 02, 2017
And I would add that since I agree that compressor settings are more complex than just “more or less,” that game probably only teaches a certain aspect of compression. I’m no expert, but that seems reasonable to me.
profile
Patrick Huber
Nov 02, 2017
close your eyes then focus on the snare sound. The uncompressed sound is often closer to your ears and the compressed sound is more in the mix.
profile
Silvano Jud
Nov 02, 2017
Yes, i agree with @patrick huber. focus on snare, check how far is it away in the stereofield, pay attention to the reverb and also the attack of the snare drum. If the SD is further away in the stereo field, then its more compressed, it pushes the sound more in the back.
profile
Casper Kramer
Nov 02, 2017
Alright, thanks guys! I was actually playing it with the less dynamic range = more compression theory, but it looked as if that wasn't always the case. But of course that could have been my own lack of good hearing. Gonna give it another shot soon!
profile
Jeffrey Jarjoura
Nov 07, 2017
+1 patrick! Dr. Compressor was my worst game until this tip. I was focusing primarily on cymbal reverb volume which was not always available depending on the random track and not nearly as consistant as the snare hit position. A combination of the two strategies has improved my scores substantially!
profile
Dian Yu
Nov 03, 2018
Thank you @Silvano Jud ! I just used this method passed the first level of Dr.Compressor finally, which I tried more than ten times before but failed... It's super helpful!
profile
Silvano Jud
Nov 03, 2018
@Dian Yu, glad to help. :-) Had the same problems, now I'm on level 125 and struggling there. Just to say, everything is possible with constant training just do your homework and you will improve.
profile
rico polo
Nov 03, 2018
I do agree that the game would be significantly more relevent if it was about judging attack or realease settings, just hearing compression is definitly not enough
profile
Bulat Danilov
Nov 03, 2018
Hate this game 😆
Tried to identify compression by the snare drum before but I guess I was trying to identify wrong properties.
Also I think it would be much more useful if it had either a more detailed explanation that "try to identify a compressed sound" or it was something like an EQ Knight game where you have to choose between different compressor settings (which could utilise all the possible uses of the compressor).
But that's beside the point basically
profile
Noam Gingold
Nov 03, 2018
As a teacher I can say that hearing compression is one of the hardest missions for students. My trick is to start with the compressor settings where compression is most prominent and easy to identify: very fast attack, very fast release, ratio 1/4 or higher, then take the threshold down and squash the sound. After you can identify compression with these extreme setting we can continue to the more subtle nuances. Thats what we did with dr. compression game, very short attack and release, high ratio. Start by listening to which sound is compressed with these extreme setting. There probably will be an advanced compression game when you have to identify different compressor parameters, but it will be aimed for those with more experience and can be overwhelming for beginners.
profile
Nikolaj Ditlevsen
Nov 03, 2018
What I'm going for in this game, is the level between the drum transients and the room. Sometimes when compressed, the transients get quieter and room stays the same, and other times the room gets louder with transients stay the same. But overall the level difference between transients and room gets smaller when compressed. This typically works for me, but try the Compressor game with different mindsets and see what works best for you.
Also try close your eyes and imagine the drummers room in your head, and then pay attention to what happens with that imaginary room when switching between the two sound clips.
profile
Arron Herring
Nov 03, 2018
Compression is hard to get you ears tuned too. listen for a lift in the ambience sound in the audio source, compression brings low level room sounds out when compression is taking place.
Hope this helps!
profile
Dylan Colby
Nov 03, 2018
What I look for while playing the compression game is for the snare drum and if the snare drum drops in volume and its consistent with the other snare drum, makes it easy to know if its compressed. Any other pro tips I can try to imply besides one technique?
profile
João Gabriel Fonseca
Aug 01, 2020
I've been practicing with soundgym for 3 days now, and the tip about how far the snare sounds is brilliant, it's definitely the best way for me